Connect with us

Support The NewsHawks

Craig Ervine (left) and Sikandar Raza have carried the team on their shoulders, but are approaching the twilight of their careers.


ZimCricket at crossroads – time to confront some uncomfortable truths




IN professional sport, change is often a bitter pill to swallow.

The perennial challenge lies in deciding when to bid farewell to legendary figures, the stalwarts who have dedicated their lives to a cause in their careers.

Zimbabwean cricket faces one such dilemma today. With a 3-2 loss in the T20I series to Namibia, it is time to confront some uncomfortable truths.

Senior players Sean Williams and Sikandar Raza are both aged 37 while their captain Craig Ervine is aged 38. They all have undoubtedly been valuable contributors to Zimbabwean cricket. Still, it may be time for them to step aside and allow the younger generation to take the reins, building a team for the future.

The weight of legacy

Sean Williams and Sikandar Raza have been the cornerstones of Zimbabwean cricket for well over a decade. Their dedication and commitment to the team are beyond question. Williams, a left-handed all-rounder, and Raza, a gritty middle-order batsman and off-spinner, have often carried the team on their capable shoulders.

Both players have a string of impressive individual records to their names. Williams has been a model of consistency, with over 7 000 runs and just under 150 wickets in international cricket across all formats.

Raza, on the other hand, has been the glue holding the middle order together, with over 6 500 runs and over 160 wickets across all formats. Their contributions to Zimbabwean cricket should not be underestimated.

The captain, Craig Ervine, has also played a crucial role. His leadership skills have steered the team through some challenging times. He has been a dependable batsman, amassing over 5 000 runs in all formats. Ervine’s captaincy has provided stability and direction, helping the team navigate the tumultuous waters of international cricket.

The harsh realities

However, it is important to look beyond the accolades and recognise that cricket is a team sport. Zimbabwe’s inability to qualify for the last two 50-over World Cup tournaments raises pertinent questions. The harsh reality is that despite the valuable contributions of Williams, Raza, and Ervine, the team’s overall performance has not been up to the mark.

Cricket World Cups are the pinnacle of the sport, and failing to secure a berth in two consecutive tournaments is a matter of great concern. It calls for introspection and strategic planning for the future. Continuing with the same set of senior players might not be the solution, given the current results.

The necessity of transition

Transition in sports is never easy. There is always an emotional attachment to legendary figures, and letting go is never straightforward. However, it is an essential part of any sport’s evolution. The time has come for Zimbabwean cricket to embrace this transition.

Cricket is a physically demanding sport, and age eventually catches up with even the most dedicated athletes. While players like Williams, Raza, and Ervine have defied age for a while, it is crucial to realise that their best years may be behind them. A transitional plan should be set in motion, focusing on grooming the next generation of talent. Young players need exposure and opportunities to develop, and this can only happen if the seniors make way for them.

Leadership change

In addition to stepping down from their playing roles, it is also time to consider a change in leadership. While Craig Ervine has led with distinction, a fresh perspective may be necessary for the team’s progress. Sometimes a new captain can inject new ideas, strategies, and motivation into the squad.

It is important to highlight the context in which David Houghton took over as the coach. Lalchand Rajput was relieved of his duties after losing heavily to Namibia and Afghanistan, then a lower-ranked team. Zimbabwean cricket was in a state of flux then, and a change in leadership was seen as a means to revitalise the team. While Houghton’s appointment might have been seen as a move in the right direction, his recent series loss to Namibia raises questions about his tenure as well.

The perils of consistency

Consistency is often seen as a virtue in cricket. However, clinging to the status quo can also be detrimental. In the case of Zimbabwean cricket, the reluctance to let go of senior players, despite diminishing returns, has hurt the team’s chances of development and growth.

Williams, Raza and Ervine are undoubtedly great servants of Zimbabwean cricket. But their continued presence may inadvertently hinder the emergence of new talent. This raises the question: is it fair to expect players in their late 30s to shoulder the responsibility of rebuilding a team and competing at the highest level?

The need for a bold vision

To move forward, Zimbabwean cricket needs a bold vision and a commitment to nurturing young talent. This may involve short-term sacrifices for long-term gains. Giving the next generation of players a chance to learn, adapt, and grow in international cricket is paramount.

Investing in youth development programmes, scouting young talents in domestic cricket, and providing them with international exposure is the way forward. A team built around promising youngsters, with the guidance of experienced mentors, can set Zimbabwean cricket on a path to resurgence.

Farewell with dignity

The decision to retire is always a deeply personal one. It should ideally be made by the players themselves, who are best placed to assess their own capabilities and contributions. The respect and dignity they have earned throughout their careers should be honoured in their exit.

Zimbabwean cricket authorities, alongside the players, should engage in open and honest discussions about their future roles. The experience and expertise of Williams, Raza and Ervine could be invaluable in mentoring and coaching the next generation. Retirement should not mean goodbye but rather a transition into new roles within the sport, continuing to serve the cause of Zimbabwean cricket.

As I conclude, I say in cricket as in life, change is inevitable. The 3-2 series loss to Namibia is a reminder that Zimbabwean cricket is at a crossroads. It is time to acknowledge the valuable contributions of senior players like Sean Williams, Sikandar Raza and Craig Ervine while also recognising that their era may be coming to an end.

The failure to secure World Cup berths in consecutive tournaments should trigger a reconsideration of the team’s composition and leadership. The time has come for a transition, where the torch is passed to the younger generation, allowing them to build a team for the future.

As fans and stakeholders of Zimbabwean cricket, we owe it to the sport we love to embrace this change with open hearts and hopeful eyes. The legacy of Williams, Raza, and Ervine will forever be etched in the annals of Zimbabwean cricket, and it is time to ensure that their contributions continue to guide the team towards a brighter future.

*Guest columnist Joseph ‘Jonty’ Madyembwa, a regular NewsHawks contributor, is a UK-based former Zimbabwe national team performance analyst and Mashonaland Eagles franchise team manager. Jonty is currently undertaking a PhD programme at Loughborough University’s Institute of Sports Business.